| Address Change | Contact Us | Where to Buy | Subscriptions
Harbor Light News | Harbor Springs, MI

home : columnists and contributors : columnists and contributors May 24, 2016

6/11/2014 12:01:00 AM
No simple solutions for Michigan's cities

By Ken Winter

There is no simple solution to bringing back Detroit or other cities.

There's also no question the 11-bill package allocating about $195 million in state funds for Detroit, championed by Gov. Rick Snyder, passed the Michigan House on May 22 and now the Michigan Senate, is becoming the deal breaker as to whether or not Detroit will move forward.

More are discovering while there are some regional differences across the state, there are many similarities not only in problems, but possible solutions. The "to-do" lists being developed by regional community leaders to work on these issues in Detroit and other parts of the state are not much different.

The difference from now and four years ago, the three-day Detroit Chamber event (held last month) now has a growing number of outside participants and speakers addressing shared concerns that need to be addressed statewide not just in Detroit-education, environment and parks, healthcare, transportation and roads to poverty, crime, the economy and jobs.

Four years ago, something changed at the Grand Hotel event. The Detroit Chamber got serious and told its membership the conference was changing. I suspect this came in large part with the appearance of its then new president and CEO, Sandy Barauh.

There would still be some fun and cocktails, but it was announced the program would be replaced with serious state and national presenters and sessions, hour after hour. This included speakers like University of Michigan president Mary Sue Coleman, Gallup CEO Jim Clifton, and author Malcolm Gladwell.

Like those at the Mackinac Conference talking about Detroit's future, there appears to be more guarded optimism among Michiganians in general, with all wanting better quality of life.

You now see more West Michigan business leaders like Doug DeVos, President of Amway; Sam Cummings, Grand Rapids real estate development expert; Rick Baker, Grand Rapids Area Chamber President & CEO, Mark Murray, President of Meijer, Inc. and former president of Grand Valley State University, even other even Upper Peninsula leaders like Amy Clickner of Marquette-based Lake Superior Community Partnership.

Barauh credits the expanding statewide circle coming from the Detroit chamber involving more people from other parts of the state in the conference, even in early planning. While partially true, others see the policy conference as a change to guard the hen house. As one western Michigan banker put it, "We didn't used to participate until four or five years ago, after we realized Detroiters were meeting with our elected state and federal representatives just before budget time and by the time we caught up with them, the deals had been made."

Like those at the Mackinac Conference talking about the future Detroit, there appears to be more guarded optimism with all wanting better quality of life.

Others like DeVos, see not much difference between the policy agendas set in Detroit than those being developed at the West Michigan Policy Forum Conference being planned for September 28-29 at the Amway Grand Plaza in Grand Rapids. Planned by West Michigan business and community leaders, the conference assembles every other year since 2008 to establish its policy agenda and unified vision not much different than Detroit. West Michigan's agenda also includes education, healthcare, labor, transportation/infrastructure and effective government.

Many from my Baby Boomer generation remember Detroit before the 1967 riots with lined streets with beautiful homes and vibrant businesses. They recall the neighboring downtown Sanders Confectionary with its chocolates and famous ice cream sodas (one of the first stores to open Sundays), Tiger Stadium (then Briggs), as well the 982-acre Belle Isle along the Detroit River with its amazing aquarium, nature conservatory and zoo, gardens and other park lands.

Now some of the area is slowly turning around, with a new downtown entertainment and sports center with other places like the revitalized Fox Theatre, Detroit Opera House and Orchestra Hall with the adjoining with the creation of an adjoining Max M. Fisher Music Center for jazz and chamber music, Comerica Park and Ford Stadium.

At the conference, newly elected Mayor Mike Duggan presented his housing demolition program to improve core Detroit neighborhoods by removing abandoned homes, improving city busing, neighbor parks and restoring street lighting-one neighborhood at a time.

Ken Winter is former editor and publisher of the Petoskey News-Review and a member of the Michigan Journalism Hall of Fame.

First Community Bank 081415_stroke

Article Comment Submission Form
Please feel free to submit your comments.

Article comments are not posted immediately to the Web site. Each submission must be approved by the Web site editor, who may edit content for appropriateness. There may be a delay of 24-48 hours for any submission while the web site editor reviews and approves it.

Note: All information on this form is required. Your telephone number is for our use only, and will not be attached to your comment.
Submit an Article Comment
First Name:
Last Name:
Anti-SPAM Passcode Click here to see a new mix of characters.
This is an anti-SPAM device. It is not case sensitive.

Advanced Search

Subscription Login

Copyright 2016 Harbor Light
Software © 1998-2016 1up! Software, All Rights Reserved